
In order to get by in life, we look to others to guide us. At the same time, we also compare ourselves to said others. We place ourselves in a hierarchy to see where we stand. While it’s important to know one’s place in the world, this can hinder someone when it’s apparent that the place may not be the right one for them. With the 1st part of Attack on Titan Season 3 finished up, the anime finally showed a key information dump that brings up issues of inferiority and envy that hurt us. It’s something that we can learn from today due to how people perceive things to be zero-sum.
Right after an uprising to overturn a corrupt government and before the expedition to retake Wall Maria for good, Eren Yeager wanted to know more about his father, Grisha. He learns from absorbed memories (due to Titan inheritance) that an old instructor of his, Keith Shadis, met and saved his father at some point. Eren, along with the Survey Corps, confronts Shadis. Shadis then tells the group about how he met Grisha as a member of the Survey Corps. He also goes on about his insecurity over being an average person who couldn’t save anyone compared to Grisha. That insecurity would lead him to try and sabotage Eren’s attempts to be a member of the military way back in the beginning, only for the strategy to backfire on him and confirm his own belief that he was powerless to change anything at all.
What Shadis goes through is pretty normal. Social comparison is a big part of how we live our lives. We want to see how we’re doing among other people. We want to see if we can copy someone to improve our lives. We all want to show that we’re better than someone who is worse off in certain areas. However, we may want love from those who may be worse off. You can say that love and envy can go hand in hand.
Shadis liked Grisha after rescuing him. He was fascinated by his lack of knowledge regarding life inside the walls. However, he begun to see Grisha’s successes as a doctor and his ability to start a family with a sense of inferiority. During Grisha’s wedding, Shadis straight up left after seeing him. At the same time, he wasn’t fulfilling his role as Commander of the Survey Corps. Shadis would later by replaced by Erwin Smith, whose creativity in setting up expeditions with minimal human loss made him a better choice for commander. He would take out his frustrations on Eren’s mother, Carla, about what it means to be an average person versus a great person.
Shadis made endless comparisons with others to the point to the point where he felt useless. As a young recruit, he was envious of his superiors and wanted to prove them wrong. But in the end, nothing changed for Shadis. Shadis was obsessed with the word “special.” Grisha once said Shadis was special for even attempting to go outside the walls. That compliment made him feel special people can change the world. Endless comparison leads to a lot of unhappiness. You can see this with regards to social media and the issue of FOMO (fear of missing out).
It’s possible that Shadis was very afraid of being disliked by others. That’s why he wanted to feel special. We want to own up to nice things people say about us. But sometimes, compliments are just meant to be compliments. Reading through Shadis’ flashback again makes me think about praise. There was a study in 1997 on a type of praise that can backfire when you use it. Basically, if you’re saying something like “You’re so smart,” “You’re amazing!”, “Good job!” to someone, that person ends up feeling pressured to live up to those labels.
This is what Grisha told Shadis when they were getting to know each other.
“You’re wiser and braver than anyone else inside the walls. The existence of the Survey Corps is living proof that the human imagination and soul are free. You’re the pride of humanity.”
The first part of this statement is fine and the praise is indeed genuine, but Shadis had low self-esteem from the beginning. In one flashback sequence, Shadis saw his superiors making snide comments about the Survey Corps and shows his desire to be Commander to show people up. So after hearing the words “pride of humanity,” it empowered him. It seemed like Shadis always wanted to live to Grisha’s ideal of him. When Grisha decides to transfer his Titan powers to Eren in order to avenge Carla, Shadis asked Grisha why Eren as he didn’t look special. Praise can have an unintended effect of forcing someone to live by another person’s vision of them and not their own. This in turn leads to self-loathing and possible harm to other people.
Praise works in some cases, but for anyone who’s felt neglected and desperately wants to be liked, it may not be the best solution. Hange Zoe criticized Shadis for not saying anything about Grisha’s last moments to the Survey Corps, as that information was important to the fate of humanity, due to his obsession with being special. Though as Levi and Eren wanted to point out, it’s not exactly his fault. There were no signs of encouragement for Shadis to challenge himself or re-think his way of thinking .
We treat life as some competitive game where winning is the only thing that matters. But as Carla once told Shadis about being average,
“Do you really have to be special? Do you really need people’s recognition? I don’t think so. At the very least, not when it comes to this child (Eren), he doesn’t need to become great. Why would he have to be better than anyone else? Just look at him. Don’t you see how cute he is? He’s already great. Because he was born into this world.”
Attack on Titan is all about spreading the wings of freedom. But as time goes on with the series, it’s also about having the courage to be disliked. Without that courage, like Shadis, we’ll be nothing more than bystanders.